Fractography as a tool to optimize joint design and the brazing process

Jakob J. Kuebler ,  Vinzenz Bissig ,  Gurdial Blugan ,  Jolanta Janczak-Rusch 

Empa Materials Science and Technology (Empa), Überlandstrasse 129, Dübendorf 8600, Switzerland


A number of factors such as the brazing filler composition, brazing process parameters, gap thickness, properties of the joining partners, joint geometry, etc., can influence brazed joint performance. The complex relationships between these parameters make joint optimization a difficult task. The effects of some of these factors can be predicted, others have to be determined after processing and joint characterization. The fractographic analysis of joints provide important information on the failure origin and hence about the “weakest link” in the joint. The comparison of the crack path with the simulated stress distribution helps to distinguish between the processing oriented and design based failures.
Ceramic-ceramic and ceramic-metal joints were brazed using different Cu- and Ag-based active brazing filler metals and characterized by four point bending tests. Si3N4/TiN was used as the ceramic partner and 14 NiCr 14 steel as the metal joining partner. AgCuInTi, AgInTi and CuSnTiZr brazing filler metals with differing amounts of the active element titanium varying between 0.6 and 10.2 wt.% and different working temperatures and ductilities. To minimize the residual stresses the AgCuInTi filler was modified with SiC particles, the brazing gap thickness was controlled in the range between 0.1 and 1 mm.
From each brazing batch the specimens with the highest and lowest values of bending strength were fractographically analyzed. Different joint failure behavior patterns were observed depending on the filler metal used. High residual stresses and weakening of the ceramic partner near the braze-ceramic interface were found to be the main causes for the failure of ceramic-metal joints brazed with CuSnTiZr. The stresses were reduced and the strength optimized by applying a Cu-interlayer. In the joints with AgCuInTi the influence of residual stresses on the mechanical strength could also be observed. Under these conditions the joints were successfully optimized.

Related papers
  1. Experimental evaluation of melting point depression in AlSi/AlN nanomultilayer system
  2. How to join heat sensitive materials?
  3. The Wetting Behaviour and Interface Structure of Unreinforced and Particle Reinforced Lead-Free Solders
  4. Optimization of particle reinforced lead-free solders
  5. Microstructural evaluation during particles addition to lead-free solders
  6. Evaluation of fibre-cement interfacial properties by SEM-based push-out tests
  7. Development of nanoparticle reinforced brazing filler metals and solders: the aspects of downscaling from micro to nanoscale
  8. Description of the mechanical performance of Cu-SnAgCu-Cu joints
  9. Size and constraining effects in lead-free solder joints
  10. Comparison of three different active filler metals used for brazing ceramic-to-ceramic and ceramic-to-metal joints
  11. On the Relief of the Residual Stresses in Ceramic-Metal Joints by a Layered Braze Structure
  12. Model for intermetallic phase and intermetallic compound solidification during diffusion soldering
  13. Transition from solidification to the first solid/solid transformation during diffusion soldering

Presentation: oral at E-MRS Fall Meeting 2005, Symposium H, by Jakob J. Kuebler
See On-line Journal of E-MRS Fall Meeting 2005

Submitted: 2005-05-31 11:22
Revised:   2009-06-07 00:44
© 1998-2017 pielaszek research, all rights reserved Powered by the Conference Engine